Judges raise concerns over new sentencing rules favoring minority groups

Judges voice unease with Sentencing Council's proposals

Despite judges expressing concerns that the new two-tier sentencing rules would "conflict with equality," the Sentencing Council pushed through the guidance last week. A consultation held prior to the announcement revealed deep unease with the proposals, prompting Justice Secretary Shabana Mahmood to demand they drop the guidance.

Fears of tipping the scale of justice

Starting from April 1, judges will consider a convict's ethnicity, religion, and gender when determining whether to impose a jail term. This move has sparked fears that it could lead to softer sentences and tip the scale of justice in favor of minority groups.

Pushback from Justice Secretary and politicians

Justice Secretary Shabana Mahmood has called in Sentencing Council bosses once again to demand the withdrawal of the guidance. Following a meeting with them, she plans to submit formal objections before the rules come into effect on April 1. Concerns have also been raised by politicians, with calls for the Sentencing Council to be scrapped to ensure fairness in sentencing.

Financial implications and delays in justice

Tory Robert Jenrick highlighted concerns about the financial impact of the new guidance, stating that it could cost the taxpayer tens of millions of pounds and disrupt the probation service's budget. Delays in the justice system could also mean victims have to wait longer for resolution.