Arkham on-chain ‘Intel Exchange’ labeled ‘snitch to earn’ by Crypto Twitter

Arkham, a “blockchain intelligence company,” announced what it’s calling the “world’s first on-chain intelligence exchange” on July 10 alongside the launch of a new coin, ARKM, through Binance’s Launchpad service.

Crypto Twitter has had a predictably split response to the announcement, with negative sentiment surrounding Arkham’s purported mission to “deanonymize the blockchain” causing some ire. Chief among the complaints, many of which describe the company’s Intel Exchange as a “snitch to earn” or “snitching as a service” program, involves Arkham's perceived role as a centralized intelligence agency.

Fuck this.

It's not even the snitch-to-earn component that I'm entirely against (it is useful as a decentralized whistleblowing dapp for public good).

The submissions end up on Arkham + Arkham Fnd is the central arbiter.

Someone should fork the contracts and decentralize this. https://t.co/hnfehiukd9

— Hudson Jameson (@hudsonjameson) July 10, 2023

As Arkham stated in its announcement thread, there are numerous positive use cases for the utilization of blockchain sleuths as information brokers. However, some experts are concerned over the potential for misuse that the exchange’s proposed business model appears to follow.

According to Arkham, users will be able to anonymously post and accept bounties for information concerning transactions on the blockchain. Once a bounty is completed, whatever entity paid out the bounty will have exclusive access to the data for a period of 90 days. Once the initial exclusivity period ends, Arkham says it will release the data to the public.

hey isn't the most profitable use of this just to put a bounty on whale wallets and then kidnap people?

like

did that come up in any meetings?

— farp (@farp_farp) July 10, 2023

Other commenters wondered what considerations Arkham had given to the notion that a bounty marketplace could put a target on the backs of whales.

Alongside the announcements, Arkham’s been accused of leaking email addresses for users who sign up for the company’s waitlist and then share the link on social media.

ABSOLUTE LMAO. ALL #ARKHAM REFERRAL LINKS SHARED ON TWITTER IS DOXXING EVERYONE BECAUSE THE EMAIL IS IN THE REFERRAL URL. @inversebrahhttps://t.co/HM6veJOmNp -> [email protected] https://t.co/1INvtXLEva pic.twitter.com/m38VnNMS8k

— m4gicpotato ⟁ (@m4gicpotato) July 10, 2023

Evidently, the web form encodes the user’s email address in simple BASE64. This makes it a trivial matter for someone to associate an email address with the Twitter account sharing the link, prompting at least some speculation that the encoding wasn't an oversight. 

One Twitter user declared that the supposed "doxxing" was intentional, adding that Arkham's "whole goal is to dox (assuming the big players), and what easier way then making it easy to decode via ref link." 

Definitely. I’m just saying it has to be intentional. Their whole goal is to dox (assuming the big players), and what easier way then making it easy to decode via ref link. It just wasn’t supposed to be exposed this early though. I might just be giving them too much credit tho

— slizzle (@zlizzle) July 10, 2023