WORLD of Warcraft Shadowlands has been out for about three months – and it’s been wildly popular.
But is the latest expansion to a 17-year-old game any good?
I’ve been playing World of Warcraft since the tail-end of The Burning Crusade, so around 13 years.
The game has changed hugely in that time, but the core bits have stayed the same: levelling, killing big bosses, battling enemies and hanging out with friends.
Shadowlands loses none of that, and feels like one of the most refined expansions so far.
The story begins with longstanding warrior-queen Sylvanas Windrunner tearing open a hole into the Shadowlands – Warcraft’s afterlife.
You’re introduced to a brand new world with one of the biggest baddies to date: the Jailer, who rules the Hades-esque Maw.
There are six zones: Bastion, Ardenweald, Maldraxxus, Revenredeth, the Maw and a new capital city called Oribos.
Each one is unique and feels very different from other Warcraft zones.
For instance, Revendreth is a vampy land filled with gothic castle, while Maldraxxus is Ardwenweald is a magical forest filled with fairies and giant worm-creatures.
The zones are beautiful: Bastion and Ardenweald are particularly easy on the eyes.
And each zone is home to a Covenant, which you’ll meet and learn about during the main quest line.
Eventually you’ll choose to join one Covenant, which opens up a new Campaign at level 60 – and gives you access to unique abilities.
Balancing classes is tricky enough, but the addition of Covenants has made it even harder.
I’ve yet to meet a Balance Druid that hasn’t been Night Fae, and Restored Shamans seem to always pick Necrolord.
Similarly, Kyrian is by-and-large the default tanking choice.
Credit to Blizzard, Covenants do manage to feel impactful without feeling totally prescriptive.
If you’re in a high-end guild, you’ll likely have one choice – or two if you’re lucky.
But several specs could choose one of three comfortably without totally savaging their gameplay.
For instance, it’s perfectly possible to play as a Havoc Demon Hunter in Venthyr, Night Fae or Kyrian.
Many casual players can simply choose the Covenant that offers their favourite lore and play style.
I’m not a fan of these borrowed-power systems, but Blizzard has done a decent job.
Covenants are also very important for dungeons in the mid-to-high level.
For Sanguine Depths, you’ll absolutely want a Venthyr for a huge damage boost.
And having a Kyrian in Necrotic Wake or Spires of Ascension can make several mob packs significantly easier.
Each Covenant has two dungeons where they can offer some added utility, which is nice.
In terms of overall class balance, there are still some teething issues.
That’s no surprise: we’re still early into the expansion.
But Fire Mages seem unstoppably strong, Resto Shaman’s have ludicrous healing throughput, Vengeance Demon Hunters are mobility kings that have been the go-to tank for three months straight, while their Havoc counterparts struggle immensely with single-target damage – and are largely absent from the PvP world.
I’d expect to see some major nerfs and buffs in patch 9.1, which is likely a few months away.
If you haven’t been playing Shadowlands, that’s good news as there’s absolutely loads of content to burn through.
But anyway playing Shadowlands since day one will now be finding themselves with less to do each week.
Pushing increasingly-difficult Mythic dungeon keys is great fun, but many players will be reaching the limits of how high their raider.io scores can go.
Similarly with Mythic Raids, we’re now seeing the final push from the remaining guilds that will manage to kill Sire Denathrius and get the coveted Cutting Edge achievement.
PvP still offers some fun, but hasn’t changed significantly for Shadowlands. A new Arena added with the expansion is decent enough, but the Rated Battleground scene has hardly changed.
Then there’s the matter of Torghast.
It’s a procedurally-generated rogue-like style dungeon that’s proved controversial since day one.
To create Legendary gear, you need to run Torghast – but many players initially complained that it takes too long, and isn’t rewarding enough.
Despite nerfs to Torghast, it still suffers from similar issues, and doesn’t do enough to entice players. The general feeling seems to be that it’s a chore, which is a shame.
I’d hope Torghast could be made quicker and more rewarding without making it unchallenging.
It needs to let players test themselves without taking up an hour or two of their time for minimal gains.
